topleft
topright

CIOZone Experts

Opinions and views from expert CIOZone members.


Jun 21
2010

What Do Good Bosses Do?

Posted by epearlman in mistakesmanagementleadershumilitygood bossconfidencebad boss

epearlman
We've all learned valuable management lessons from the mistakes of BP's chief executive Tony Hayward. Hayward has made a science out of putting his foot in his mouth and claiming ignorance of most matters that took place under his watch. It's certainly not easy being a leader when disaster strikes, but his ineptness and insensitivity makes me think he was probably not a very good leader even before the oil spill occurred.

 

One of my favorite management experts, Robert Sutton, Professor of Management Science and Engineering at Stanford University, is currently working on a book called "Good Boss, Bad Boss" (coming out in September). In a recent blog at Harvard Business Review, Sutton listed 12 key beliefs held by the best bosses. It's a great list and I recommend reading them all , but I'll focus on just a few of my favorites here:

 

"Having ambitious and well-defined goals is important, but it is useless to think about them much. My job is to focus on the small wins that enable my people to make a little progress every day."

 

That belief hit a nerve with me since I've been subject in the past to bosses that liked to do a lot of posturing about the company's BHAG (big hairy audacious goal, a term coined by James Collins and Jerry Porras in an article in 1996). Pursuers of this goal can sometimes lose sight of the small, day-to-day things that make big visions achievable, as well as the rank-and-file employees who are often responsible for these small wins (notice I didn't use the phrase "small people" after BP's chairman made that huge blunder). And while a BHAG is supposed to unify employees in a common goal, it can also be so ambitious that is has the opposite effect-turning people off to what they view as unrealistic. In addition, if a company changes its BHAG fairly often, one comes to view it as just another meaningless phrase that no one will pay attention to and will fade from the corporate lexicon quickly.

 

"I strive to be confident enough to convince people that I am in charge, but humble enough to realize that I am often going to be wrong."

 

Getting the right balance between confidence and humility is tricky, but good bosses make it look effortless. That's because they know that all people make mistakes and they don't go ballistic when that happens. Their direct reports will make mistakes, people throughout the organization will make mistakes, and most important of all they will make mistakes. It's not the mistake that's the problem; it's how a leader handles that error that will set the tone for the entire organization. Which leads to one last maxim of good bosses:

 

"One of the best tests of my leadership-and my organization-is ‘what happens after people make a mistake.' "

 

If you've ever been chewed out by a boss and made to feel like a fool, you probably never felt comfortable around that person again. You may, in fact, have left the organization or been fired. The damage that is done to the person who made the mistake as well as to the people around him who witness the bosses heated reaction is irreversible. Moreover, if the environment is toxic for those who make mistakes, no one will ever want to own up to one. Which can mean that far greater damage occurs as people try to cover up the problem.

 

What good behavior stands out in your mind from the best bosses you've come across?

 

 

 

Comments (3)Add Comment
0
...
written by 277cindy, June 22, 2010
I agree with the first and third points very much.

For the first point, if the bosses just focus on the big goals, employees may feel it's too big to achieve and have no idea how to make relevant progress in daily life. It could be nice if the big goals can be splitted into several small ones and the roadmap is set up. Growing with the company is the employee's honor, but sometimes it's the bosses' responsibility to show employees how to do it.

For the third point, especially for the immature company that has no well-defined stardard operation manuals, bosses could be more tolerant to his own and employee's mistakes. Being open and learning from those mistakes, both can prove to be better.
0
...
written by LesF, June 22, 2010
In the UK I had worked in large global companies and now I am in Australia much smaller companies. There is an enormous gap if the professionalism of management as a whole. I witness bosses "losing it" constantly, and these are well paid exec's. Mistakes are opportunities, opportunities to identify, review and improve.
In one large global corporation when I set my goals, they had to align to the CEO's direction the organisation was heading, so we could see how our contribution fed the goals of the CEO. I haven't had goals since I left the UK, but I've had a lot of blunt unprofessional leaders.
Mel Duvall
...
written by Mel Duvall, June 22, 2010
Good point about mistakes being opportunities to identify, review and improve. I've always respected the view at Toyota (at least in the early days) when they viewed every defect found on the manufacturing line as an opportunity to improve the quality of their products.

Many organizations - and bosses - would be well served to take a similar viewpoint towards mistakes.

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy




White Paper Library

Copyright © 2007-2013 CIOZones. All Rights Reserved. CIOZone is a property of PSN, Inc.